From owner-sc35wg2+sc35wg2-domo2=www.open-std.org@open-std.org  Tue Jan 28 00:16:22 2014
Return-Path: <owner-sc35wg2+sc35wg2-domo2=www.open-std.org@open-std.org>
X-Original-To: sc35wg2-domo2
Delivered-To: sc35wg2-domo2@www.open-std.org
Received: by www.open-std.org (Postfix, from userid 521)
	id 44775358586; Tue, 28 Jan 2014 00:16:21 +0100 (CET)
Delivered-To: sc35wg2@open-std.org
X-Greylist: delayed 3601 seconds by postgrey-1.34 at www5.open-std.org; Tue, 28 Jan 2014 00:16:20 CET
Received: from smtp.usask.ca (smtp.usask.ca [128.233.192.40])
	by www.open-std.org (Postfix) with ESMTP id DFD1D3567F1;
	Tue, 28 Jan 2014 00:16:20 +0100 (CET)
Received: from conversion-daemon.usask.ca by usask.ca
 (Sun Java(tm) System Messaging Server 7.3-11.01 64bit (built Sep  1 2009))
 id <0N0200H00Z478K00@usask.ca>; Mon, 27 Jan 2014 16:16:17 -0600 (CST)
Received: from CAMPUSCAS4.usask.ca (campuscas4.usask.ca [128.233.194.195])
 by usask.ca
 (Sun Java(tm) System Messaging Server 7.3-11.01 64bit (built Sep  1 2009))
 with ESMTPS id <0N02009ZTZ75W2A0@usask.ca>; Mon,
 27 Jan 2014 16:16:17 -0600 (CST)
Received: from CAMPUSMB3.usask.ca ([fe80::e187:90d:c433:4ada])
 by CAMPUSCAS4.usask.ca ([::1]) with mapi id 14.03.0174.001; Mon,
 27 Jan 2014 16:16:17 -0600
Date: Mon, 27 Jan 2014 22:16:17 +0000
From: "Carter, James" <carter@cs.usask.ca>
Subject: RE: (SC35WG6.156) JTC1/SC35 meeting - Barcelona,
 week of 10 February 2014
In-reply-to: <20140127221247.7206A358590@www.open-std.org>
X-Originating-IP: [174.2.186.53]
To: ALB <alabon@gmail.com>, "choukri@elda.org" <choukri@elda.org>,
 "yoshikazu-seki@aist.go.jp" <yoshikazu-seki@aist.go.jp>,
 "jeeink@gmail.com" <jeeink@gmail.com>,
 "monique.mai@orange.com" <monique.mai@orange.com>,
 "keld@keldix.com" <keld@keldix.com>,
 "thibault.grouas@culture.gouv.fr" <thibault.grouas@culture.gouv.fr>
Cc: "sc35wg1@open-std.org" <sc35wg1@open-std.org>,
 "philippe.magnabosco@afnor.org" <philippe.magnabosco@afnor.org>,
 mouradi amelle <amelle.mouradi@afnor.org>,
 "sc35wg2@open-std.org" <sc35wg2@open-std.org>,
 "sc35wg4@open-std.org" <sc35wg4@open-std.org>,
 "sc35wg6@open-std.org" <sc35wg6@open-std.org>,
 "sc35wg8@open-std.org" <sc35wg8@open-std.org>
Message-id: <E7F1C154F2A96D4CA531683567BE46344A22390A@CAMPUSMB3.usask.ca>
MIME-version: 1.0
Content-type: multipart/alternative;
 boundary="Boundary_(ID_NPWKgRaARwrsQpvMGIKavA)"
Content-language: en-GB
Accept-Language: en-GB, en-US
Thread-topic: (SC35WG6.156) JTC1/SC35 meeting - Barcelona,
 week of 10 February 2014
Thread-index: AQHPGpmiGH3sAjREJk+PGpgYpV8jFpqZZSIA//+/oQE=
X-MS-Has-Attach:
X-MS-TNEF-Correlator:
References: <20140122172940.B3F8C3584AA@www.open-std.org>
 <20140123112109.0C7A03584A4@www.open-std.org>
 <7.0.1.0.2.20140123085015.07914c90@gmail.com>
 <E7F1C154F2A96D4CA531683567BE46344A21CB4B@CAMPUSMB3.usask.ca>
 <52E233C9.2050607@elda.org> <20140124100646.E127A3584D1@www.open-std.org>
 <20140124102540.3546D3584D0@www.open-std.org>
 <20140125131729.GA30991@www5.open-std.org>
 <20140125134111.7A7B2358497@www.open-std.org>
 <20140126090701.E8D5735837D@www.open-std.org>
 <20140126101336.54A9B3583DC@www.open-std.org>
 <0283A317-7EFC-4E35-8E2C-95717C3C76AA@elda.org>
 <20140127221247.7206A358590@www.open-std.org>
Sender: owner-sc35wg2@open-std.org
Precedence: bulk


--Boundary_(ID_NPWKgRaARwrsQpvMGIKavA)
Content-type: text/plain; charset=Windows-1252
Content-transfer-encoding: QUOTED-PRINTABLE

On behalf or WG6 and WG7, I agree with Alain's position.

There are many activities in SC35 that involve multiple WGs and the f=
inal resolutions session of our GOMs has played an important role in =
both achieving agreement and in formalizing actions coming out of our=
 various WG meetings. Not having such a meeting and then waiting for =
a letter ballot would be very inefficient.

Regards, Jim Carter, convenor WG6 and WG7
________________________________
=46rom: owner-sc35wg6@open-std.org [owner-sc35wg6@open-std.org] on be=
half of ALB [alabon@gmail.com]
Sent: 27 January 2014 14:03
To: choukri@elda.org; yoshikazu-seki@aist.go.jp; jeeink@gmail.com; mo=
nique.mai@orange.com; keld@keldix.com; Carter, James; thibault.grouas=
@culture.gouv.fr
Cc: sc35wg1@open-std.org; philippe.magnabosco@afnor.org; mouradi amel=
le; sc35wg2@open-std.org; sc35wg4@open-std.org; sc35wg6@open-std.org;=
 sc35wg8@open-std.org
Subject: (SC35WG6.156) JTC1/SC35 meeting - Barcelona, week of 10 Febr=
uary 2014

   The only misunderstanding, Khalid, is about the resolution meeting=
 that has been going on smoothly in the past years in absence of the =
secretary for interim meetings (non-Plenary with an upper-case P). AF=
NOR had come with a concept, the GOM (General Orientation meeting, a =
small plenary, in fact a resolution meeting) which was (and should co=
ntinue to be according to the reactions seen) a resolution meeting af=
ter WG meetings. The resolutions were then executable immediately wit=
hout the need for a letter ballot (which would be an extra administra=
tive burden, as P- countries have quorum to decide directcly at the m=
eeting).

   The only case where I have seen a resolution being sent for letter=
 ballot after a meeting is recent, when the resolution had not been n=
oted in official resolutions of a meeting and adoption then remaining=
 uncertain. If this would becore a custom, that would be is an uncess=
ary delay, an extra element thant would make sure things will not be =
done on time. But in a GOM, resolutions were always adopted by HoDs o=
f represented countries. There is no reason to fix what is not broken=
, and thisGOM  process has always been working very well so far, it i=
s very far to be broken. On the contrary, if we modify this process, =
other things will be more broken than ever, imho.

   What is broken is that many times resolutions are not executed pro=
mptly, without me wanting here to discuss about responsibilities (whi=
ch are not always the fact of one person). Our goal should be that re=
solutions be executed so that the work be done and publications achie=
ved. This process is broken, still, and should be fixed as smoothly a=
s possible.

   GOMS are a winning process and should continue for interim meeting=
s. This is what I had understood in Saskatoon, and it seems it was un=
derstood by others too (so far unanimously), according to the reactio=
ns seen of the WG1 forum.

Alain
______________________________________
Le 2014-01-26 =E0 08:22, Khalid Choukri a =E9crit :
Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64Dear colleagues

Let me first express some astonishment regarding the reactions I have=
 read since Alain's email about the plenary versus GOM  meetings, and=
 our SC35 plans.

I think we devote time to discuss this issue in Saskatoon and reviewe=
d all arguments pros and cons and the main conclusion was that we hea=
d to an annual meeting with a plenary, a WG meetings, and a resolutio=
n session; all running over 4 to 5 days.

The intermediate meeting (the one in February this year) would be tur=
ned into a meeting of experts as required by the corresponding WG age=
nda (which means some WGs would skip that meeting if no item requires=
 a face to face meeting).


So again, the proposed modus operandi as We discussed it in Saskatoon=
 would be:

1/ (As long as necessary) a winter/spring technical meeting to addres=
s and make progress on technical matters that may (or not) lead to re=
solutions. This could be an opportunity to finalize WG reports that r=
equire face to face meeting of all experts.

2/ An annual meeting with a plenary session to review the work progre=
ss, including the secretariat work and WG resolutions

3/ if a decision/action is taken during the technical meeting, the se=
cretariat will turn this into a resolution and bring it to adoption (=
electronic vote) and ensure its execution,

We also discussed the scheduling of our meetings and many requirement=
s and desiderata were expressed: I would like to ensure participation=
 of all delegates (which excludes the major holiday seasons e.g. Chri=
stmas, Chinese new year, etc.) and necessitates a consensus for two-t=
hree years in advance.

I have asked Philippe to circulate the details of the Barcelona meeti=
ng, I hope we will get it tomorrow (Monday). I understand that most o=
f us are upset because of the missing agenda and plans 10 days before=
 the meeting. I hope that you made your arrangements for your flights=
 and will share with you informations on accommodations this week.

Best regards
Khalid


> Le 26 janv. 2014 =E0 11:13, Yoshikazu SEKI <yoshikazu-seki@aist.go.=
jp> a =E9crit :
>
> Dear All,
B=8F=88H[=DB=C8=DD\=DC=80t Alain's position.
>
> We need to gather conclusions of WGs' meetings somehow, and also ne=
ed to have opportunity to know WGs' activities. We also need to decid=
e consolidated next actions after the meeting.
>
=98\=D9Y=DB=88=D3=C0M model, we can have Resolutions even in the meet=
ing where the secretary is absent.
>
=99\=DD=99Y=D8\=99=CBB=8F=88B=82=AD=F0shikazu Seki
B=8F=88B=8F=88=8CM=CCK=CC=8D=88M=CE=8DNx=E0 O[=DB=9A\]YK=9BXZP=C0rang=
e.com> <monique.mai@orange.com> =E3=81=AE=E3=83=A1=E3=83=BC=E3=83=
=AB=EF=BC=9A
B=80>> Dear all,
=88B=8F=82f=97'7B=F6b=C6=C2=C2=92v=F7V=C6B=C6=AD=B6RF=F2v=976=82you a=
 happy new year 2014 (sorry for sending this message late (my dad pas=
s away at the end of 2013 and I was pretty busy in the begin of the n=
ew year.)
>B=8F=8F=88=D9[=D9Hneed a "strong cooperation between WG's in SC35" a=
nd I fully understand, support Allan's position.
=88B=8F=82=F6b6=F0urse, the model adapted during the last session can=
 save of course expenses. Nethertheless, it really seems to me that t=
he needs of a global meeting for having an overview of the activities=
 of the different subgroup and the opportunity to get an exchange in =
face to face could be e an opportunity to wrap up the seminar, stimul=
ate by this method the cooperation and a team spirit within the SC35.=
 The collective creativity can emerge and I am sure it could be final=
ly an opportunity to stimulate all the energies in favour our trement=
ous goal "the accessibility".
>B=80>> If it is necessary, I propose to help Allan or to act for wri=
tting the resolutions if Philippe is not here (of course with his sup=
port).
>B=8F=8F=88]YH=DB=9B=DD=C8Y=88\=C8roposal can help ; my current visio=
n is that a tremendous job was done and the cohesion of the SC35 is e=
ssential.
=88B=8F=82f=F7"=AD=F7W"=AD=E6f=F7&=D6F=AD=F6=E2=C2FV=E6=9726=8C:=A6=
=E6R=E6B=D7=976V=C6bttend the Barcelone meeting. We really think that=
 we have to take in account the Allan, Keld, Jim comments.
=88@
>=99\=DD=99Y=D8\=99=CBB=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E2=D6=F6=E6=97VP=D0=A3=E3=E2=
=D0 =F8=804(=F8
>>
>
>B=8F=8F=88B=83=E2=D0=A3Q=94=80=E8=81=BD=DD=B9=95=C8=B5=CD=8C=CC=D5=
=DD=9C=C5=BDU=B8=B5=CD=D1=90=B9=BD=C9=9C=81m=B5=84ilto:owner-sc35wg1@=
open-std.org] De la part de ALB
>[=80voy=E9 : samedi 25 janvier 2014 14:41
=880=E0=88=D9[=D9[^.com; Jee-In Kim
>> Cc : Carter, James; Khalid CHOUKRI; sc35wg1@open-std.org; philippe=
.magnabosco@afnor.org; amelle.mouradi@afnor.org
>=D8=9A=99]=88
=D0=CC=CDU=D1=CCK=8DNJH=91N=88=98Y=9DAgenda - JTC1/SC35/WG1 meeting -=
 Barcelona, week of 10 February 2014
>B=8F=8F=88H=8CMLKL=8DH0=E8=8CM=CB=D9[=D9[^=98=C0om =E9crit:
>>X\=88[B=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8=81$=81=85=B1=CD=BC=81=CD=D5A=BD=C9=D0=
=81=B1=85=A5=B8=9Cs propositions.
=8F=88B=83=E3=E2=92=E6=F7FRF=86BF=86Rtw2v=AD=C6=C2=86fP resolutions, =
and that these resolutions should
>=88=99H=C0arried out bu the SC without unnessecary delay, eg. confir=
med via a
>>=D0=C8]\=88=98[=DD\=C8=D9H\=D9H=C8=C8=DA[=88=D9@ run GOMs.
>>
=88=D0[Z[=97H[=88=98X=DDY=9D\=88[=D3=D3\=CB=99\=C0olutions were execu=
ted, we have not done letter ballots to vote on these resolutions lat=
er on.
>B=8F=8F=88=9D]=DA[=88a ballot was called by a resolution for a NP, C=
D, DIS, PDTR, etc,, this ballot was done without extra formality . Th=
is is the typical situation for most resolutions.
=88@
>\=C8\=C8H[=DC=DDY=99=9AX=DAY[=9D=D8^H=C8=9B=D8=D9YY[Z=9BB=8F=8F=88
=88[Z[=83B=8F=8F=88B=83=E3=E2&W2&Vv&G0=D0=A3=E0=F8=81-=95=B1=904(>>
=8F=82=F6=E0 Fri, Jan 24, 2014 at 07:25:28PM +0900, Jee-In Kim wrote:
=8F=82FV"=C6=C2=A3=E3=E0=F8=804(=F8>> I also support Alain's position=
 and interpretation.
=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=81]=94=81=C9=95=85=B1=B1=E4=81=B9=95=95=90=81=
=84=81=CD=D0rong cooperation between WG's in SC35.
>=8F=88=9B=DC=88^[\K we received a lot of valuable comments from expe=
rts in all WG's in SC35 to the 30113 series of gesture interfaces. Th=
at seems to me one of the great advantages of the GOM model. I expect=
 that we need more cooperation in the future.
>>=88B=8F=83=E3=E2=C76=F2=C2vR6=E2&RfW'=92&=F6GV7F=97fRv=97F=82F=80e =
GOM model while relieving burdens and expenses of the secretariat. Th=
is seems a very practical solution to me.
>>=88B=8F=83=E3=E2&W7B=A3=E0=F8=F8=81)=95=94=B5%=B8=81-=A5=B4=80=A1=
=A5A=85=90=A44(=F8>>
=8F=82#14. 1. 24. =CF=F3=F2s=A3b$6'FW"=C2=A6=D6W2"=C66'FW$72=E7W66=
=B2=E60a> ??=CF=E0=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=804(=F8>>H=99[Y]=99H]\=99H\=99H=
=98\=9A[=DD\=C0 interpretations of what we discussed. Alain definitel=
y discussed the GOM model as a means of meeting without plenary in th=
e Saskatoon discussions. Given the context of history within SC35, ma=
ny participants have a valid expectation that that was what was agree=
d to.
>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8=81I=95=9Cards, Jim
=8F=83=E2g&=F6=D3=A2=B6=86=C6=ADB4=84=F5T=B5$=92=B66=86=F7V=B7&=94V=
=C6F=E6=F7&u=D0=D0
>=8F=826V=E7C=A2#B=A6=E7V'=92#B3=A33P=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8=81Q=BC=E8=
=81
=85=C9=D1=95=C8=B0=81)=85=B4es; ALB; sc35wg1@open-std.org
>=8F=8263=A2=86=AD=C6=97R=E6=D6v=E6&=F0sco@afnor.org; amelle.mouradi@=
afnor.org
=8F=83=E27V&=A6V7C=A2e: (SC35WG1.492) Draft Agenda - JTC1/SC35/WG1 me=
eting - Barcelona, week of 10 February 2014
>>=8F=88B=83=E3=E0=F8=81!=A4=81)=A5=B44
>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8=81Q=A1=A5=CC=81=A5=CC=81=DD=A1=85=D0=81=
=DD=94=81=91=A5=CD=8D=D5=CD=CD=95=90=81=85=B1=B0=81=D1=BD=9D=95=D1=
=A1=95=C8=81=89=BD=D0h in Busan and Saskatoon and, after the discussi=
ons, I announced that we are heading towards an annual plenary meetin=
g with, as many as required, technical meetings.
=8F=80> The agreement was that we have our plenaries in the summer (e=
nd of June, early July) and a technical one in February this time.
=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8 Philippe:  Could you please circulate the in=
fo on the February meeting
=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0>>B=8F=8F=83=E3=E2&W7B&Vv&G2F=F2=C6=C2=A3=E0=F8=
=F8 Khalid
>>=8F=88B=80>>=88=D8\=9D\=8B=98[Y\=C8=DC=9B=DDK=DB=88=8D=CCK=CC=8CM=
=8D=CE=83B=8F=8F=83=E3d=80strongly agree with Alain that the GOM mode=
l that we have historically used works well to promote the well being=
 and success of SC35 and that to do less would be to invite major pro=
blems in the working and success of SC35.
=8F=80>>
=8F=83=E3=E2&Vv&G2=C2=A6=AD=D0=D0 =F8=F8>> __________________________=
______
>=8F=83=E2g&=F6=D3=A2=C4"=B6=C6&=F6=E4v=D6=AD=A66=F6=D5=D0=D0 =F8=
=F8>> Sent: 23 January 2014 08:25
=8F=83=E3=E2F=F3=A2=B6=86=C6=ADB4=84=F5T=B5$=93=B2633Pwg1@open-std.or=
g
>>=8F=8263=A2=86=AD=C6=97R=E6=D6v=E6&=F766=F4f=E6=F7"=E6=F7 g; amelle=
.mouradi@afnor.org; Carter, James
=8F=83=E3=E27V&=A6V0t: Re: (SC35WG1.492) Draft Agenda - JTC1/SC35/WG1=
 meeting - Barcelona, week of 10 February 2014
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8> Khalid,
=8F=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8>> OK, I updated the timeframe of the agenda (s=
ee attached file, 2nd draft agenda).
>=8F=83=E2=D0
>=8F=83=E2=86=F7vWfW"=92F=86=AD=E6=B2F=86BF=86W&R6=86=F7V=C6B&R=D2=
=D22vR=86`e always done -- a P plenary session at the end to have con=
solidated resolutions, not dispersed resolutions in each WG (AFNOR us=
ed to call such a meeting a GOM [General Orientation Meeting, a term =
invented by them for meetings where the secretariat was absent, a sit=
uation with which we got used to and to which we adapted as it seemed=
 the best solution in this case] when it was not a formal Plenary). O=
therwise I strongly fear that SC35 will be weakened, disorganized, an=
d incoherent between formal plenaries (we need to be sure that decisi=
ons will be cared about and focused in a central point). The sentimen=
t of "belonging" will also vanish, and groups will feel autonomous (l=
et's then form a different SC !) or not cared about (one situation or=
 the other, not much in between). The net result, imho, will be that =
interest in attendance could go down. That is my experience of JTC1  =
    meetings since more than a quarter century.
>>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 We have always have consolidated resolutio=
ns since the creation of SC35 in 1999 (SC35 was created by JTC1 at it=
s Rio de Janeiro Plenary in January 1999, I was there -- out of JTC1/=
WG5, itself out of JTC1/SC18/WG9). This strenghtened SC35 all the tim=
e, making it a coherent body. When the secretary was not there, I was=
 acting as resolution secretary (no problem in my doing so again, and=
 many other people could also do so -- in any way I can still volunte=
er if this is a problem).
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8> About future meetings, I think that we mus=
t have strong hints (at least a firm date and a firm continent, ideal=
ly a firm country) for 18 months in advance (funds planning is typica=
lly done -- depending on countries -- on a civil year, from January t=
o December or from another month up to the next eleven months over sp=
anning civil years [in Canada as a case in point from April to March =
of the next civil year). In absence of those strong hints, funds have=
 more chances not to be sufficiently available, which is also very mu=
ch detrimental to sustainable attendance.
>>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 I'm pretty sure that other convenors will =
agree with me. If not, I'm ready to modestly say I have a dissident v=
iew and would then accept the views of the majority.
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8> Alain
>>=8F=82=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=
=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F0=D0=A3=
=E3=E0=F8=F8 Le 2014-01-23 =E0 06:13, Khalid CHOUKRI a =E9crit :
>=8F=83=E2=D0
>=8F=83=E2=86=92=C6=AD=E0=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8
>>=8F=822w&VVBB=F7W"66=B6@oon meeting there will be no "Plenary" sess=
ions per see in Barcelona,
=8F=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8>> I hope to join the group and introduce the a=
ctivities of the week but this could be an informal introduction on M=
onday morning , Philippe is looking at that and this should not last =
more than 30mn;
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8> The same decision impacts the closing sess=
ion (there will be no closing meeting and hence no resolution session=
), I hope to be able to attend a general gathering (may be on Thursda=
y) to wrap up and see how we move forward with respect to the July me=
eting.
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0>>=88=99Y=D8\=99[=99=C8[=DD\=88][H=DB=88=9D]\=99HY=
Y][=99=DC=C8H=DDY=D9=D9\=DD=C8leave this out unless you would like to=
 get the participants desiderata (and hopefully Philippe will circula=
te the invitation from our Chinese partners before Barcelona)
>>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 thanks again and best wishes to all for a =
successful meeting in Barcelona
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8> Khalid
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8> P.S. Philippe: could you please update the=
 SC35 action list, in particular with the information you got from Sp=
ain, thanks
>>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8
>>=8F=82=C6=AD=E0 LaBont=EF=B0=AFH=DC=9B=DDK=DB=88=8C=8B=CCK=CC=8CMN=
=8C=8EN=83B=8F=83=E3=E0=F8=81M=95=94=81=85=D1=D0ached file. Please in=
dicate omissions, errors, if any, and suggest other areas of concerns=
.
>>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 Any other remark also welcome.
>>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 Alain LaBont=E9, Convenor, JTC1/SC35/WQG1
>=8F=83=E2\:=AD&V0=D0 =F8=F8>>
=8F=80>> ---
=8F=83=E3=E26R6=F7W'&=ADW":=AD=C6V7G&=F6=E6=97VR=E6R6=F6=E7F=ADV=E7BV=
7Pn virus ou logiciel malveillant parce que la protection avast! Anti=
virus est active.
=8F=83=E3=E2=87GG=A2=F2=F7wwr=E6f7B=E66=F6=D2
=8F=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8>> --
>=8F=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8> Khalid Choukri
>>>>S=90H=D9[=99\=98[=D9X=DC=99]\=9EH    =88SH=D1S=C2=8F=8F=83=E3U=
=B5=85=A5=B0=E8=81=8D=A1=BD=D4kri@elda.org< mailto:choukri@elda.org>;
=8F=83=E3=E2vV#=A2wwr=E0elra.info < http://www.elra.info=DD=DD=CB=
=99[K=9B=DC=99=C8=8B=CB=DD=C0ww.elda.org/<UrlBlockedError.aspx>>
>>=8F=82FV=A2=B332C223232=D2f=82=E2=B33243 13 33 30
=8F=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8>> ********************************************=
*******
=8F=83=E3=E2=A2=A2=AD=E6f=F2=F6=E2=C5$T3=A2wwr=E6=C7&Pc-conf.org < ht=
tp://www.lrec-conf.org<http://www.lrec-conf.org/>>
>=8F=83=E2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2 *******************************=
***********
=8F=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8>>
=8F=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8>>
=8F=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8>> ________________________________
>=8F=83=E2=B2=87GG=A2=F2=F77FF=AD2=E6f7B=E66=F6=D2=F6V=D6=AD=C72=F6va=
st-mail-stamp.png] < http://www.avast.com/B=83=E3=E0=F8=F8=804(>>=
=8F=88=D9H=DB=DD\=9C=9AY\=880=EA[X=DD=9B=DB=9A\]YH=99H=DB=DB=9DY[=
=9D]X=DD[=88=9A\=9D\=C8=C0u<http://www.avast.com/B=83%E3%E0%F8%F8=
=804(%3E%3E%8F=88%D9H%DB%DD/=9C=9AY/=880%EA%5BX%DD=9B%DB=9A/%5DYH=
=99H%DB%DB%9DY%5B%9D%5DX%DD%5B=88=9A/%9D/%C8%C0u> logiciel malveillan=
t parce que la protection Antivirus avast!< http://www.avast.com/\=
=DDX=DD]=99K=83B=83=E3=E0=F8=804(=F8<http://www.avast.com//%DDX%DD%5D=
=99K=83B=83%E3%E0%F8=804(%F8>>> --
>>=8F=88B=83=E3=E0=F8=81-=A1=85=B1=A5=90=81
=A1=BD=D5=AD=C9=A4=804(=F8>>S=90H=D9[=99\=98[=C0ecretary & ELDA CEO
>=8F=82V=D6=AD=E26=86=F7V=B7&=94V=C6F=E6=F7&s=B2=D0=A3=E0>>=D9X=8E=
=88=DD=DD=CB=99[=98K=9A[=99=9B=C8=DD=DD=CB=99[K=9B=DC=99=C8B=83=E3=
=E0=F8=81Q=95=B0=B8=80=AC=CC=CC=80=C4=80=D0=CC 13 33 33 - Fax. +33 1 =
43 13 33 30
>=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8=80=A8=A8=A8=A8=A8=A8***********************=
**********************
=8F=83=E2=A2=A2=90nfo on LREC: www.lrec-conf.org<http://www.lrec-conf=
.org/>
>>=8F=88
=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=80***************=
*******************
>>
=88B=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E2Ce courrier =E9lectronique ne contient aucun vi=
rus ou logiciel malveillant parce que la protection Antivirus avast! =
est active.
=88B=8F=82=D0=A3=E3=E2=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=
=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F0________________________=
___________________________________________________________________
>>
=88=D9HY\=DC=D8Y=D9H] ses pieces jointes peuvent contenir des informa=
tions confidentielles ou privilegiees et ne doivent donc
>\=C8@tre diffuses, exploites ou copies sans autorisation. Si vous av=
ez recu ce message par erreur, veuillez le signaler
=88H       =D9^Y]]\=88]H]=9DZ\=99HZ[=9C=DAH]YH\=C8YX=D9\=C8=80ointes.=
 Les messages electroniques etant susceptibles d'alteration,
>> Orange decline toute responsabilite si ce message a ete altere, de=
forme ou falsifie. Merci.
>>
> This message and its attachments may contain confidential or privil=
eged information that may be protected by law;
>> they should not be distributed, used or copied without authorisati=
on.
=88Y=88[=DDH]=99H=99X=D9Z]=99Y\=C8[XZ[[=80 error, please notify the s=
ender and delete this message and its attachments.
>\=C8[XZ[=C8X^H=99H[\=99Y=DC=98[=99=D9@ is not liable for messages th=
at have been modified, changed or falsified.
>[=9A=C8[=DDK=83B=8F=88B=82=D0=A3=E2=D0=A3=E2=D2=D2=D0 =804(> Yoshika=
zu SEKI, Ph.D.
> Senior Research Scientist
> Physical Fitness Technology Group*,
> Human Technology Research Institute,
> National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology (A=
IST).

=88=DC=9B=DD\=DA[=99=D9Y=80une 1, 2013.
B=8F=88KLKLHY=D8\=DAK=DDZ=DDX=98KX=98\=98Z=DAH=CC
KN566 JAPAN.
> Phone: +81-29-861-6716,
> Fax: +81-29-861-6774  *Fax number also changed.
> E-mail: yoshikazu-seki@aist.go.jp
> Web : http://staff.aist.go.jp/yoshikazu-seki/
B=80


________________________________
[http://static.avast.com/emails/avast-mail-stamp.png] <http://www.ava=
st.com/>

Ce courrier =E9lectronique ne contient aucun virus ou logiciel malvei=
llant parce que la protection Antivirus avast!<http://www.avast.com/>=
 est active.



--Boundary_(ID_NPWKgRaARwrsQpvMGIKavA)
Content-type: text/html; charset=Windows-1252
Content-transfer-encoding: QUOTED-PRINTABLE

<html dir=3D"ltr">
<head>
<meta http-equiv=3D"Content-Type" content=3D"text/html; charset=3DWin=
dows-1252">
<style id=3D"owaParaStyle" type=3D"text/css">P {margin-top:0;margin-b=
ottom:0;}</style>
</head>
<body ocsi=3D"0" fpstyle=3D"1">
<div style=3D"direction: ltr;font-family: Tahoma;color: #000000;font-=
size: 10pt;">On behalf or WG6 and WG7, I agree with Alain's position.
<br>
<br>
There are many activities in SC35 that involve multiple WGs and the f=
inal resolutions session of our GOMs has played an important role in =
both achieving agreement and in formalizing actions coming out of our=
 various WG meetings. Not having such a meeting and
 then waiting for a letter ballot would be very inefficient.<br>
<br>
Regards, Jim Carter, convenor WG6 and WG7<br>
<div style=3D"font-family: Times New Roman; color: #000000; font-size=
: 16px">
<hr tabindex=3D"-1">
<div style=3D"direction: ltr;" id=3D"divRpF590019"><font color=3D"#00=
0000" size=3D"2" face=3D"Tahoma"><b>From:</b> owner-sc35wg6@open-std.=
org [owner-sc35wg6@open-std.org] on behalf of ALB [alabon@gmail.com]<=
br>
<b>Sent:</b> 27 January 2014 14:03<br>
<b>To:</b> choukri@elda.org; yoshikazu-seki@aist.go.jp; jeeink@gmail.=
com; monique.mai@orange.com; keld@keldix.com; Carter, James; thibault=
.grouas@culture.gouv.fr<br>
<b>Cc:</b> sc35wg1@open-std.org; philippe.magnabosco@afnor.org; moura=
di amelle; sc35wg2@open-std.org; sc35wg4@open-std.org; sc35wg6@open-s=
td.org; sc35wg8@open-std.org<br>
<b>Subject:</b> (SC35WG6.156) JTC1/SC35 meeting - Barcelona, week of =
10 February 2014<br>
</font><br>
</div>
<div></div>
<div><font size=3D"3">&nbsp;&nbsp; The only misunderstanding, Khalid,=
 is about the resolution meeting that has been going on smoothly in t=
he past years in absence of the secretary for interim meetings (non-P=
lenary with an upper-case P). AFNOR had come with a concept, the
 GOM (General Orientation meeting, a small plenary, in fact a resolut=
ion meeting) which was (and should continue to be according to the re=
actions seen) a resolution meeting after WG meetings. The resolutions=
 were then executable immediately without the need
 for a letter ballot (which would be an extra administrative burden, =
as P- countries have quorum to decide directcly at the meeting).<br>
<br>
&nbsp;&nbsp; The only case where I have seen a resolution being sent =
for letter ballot after a meeting is recent, when the resolution had =
not been noted in official resolutions of a meeting and adoption then=
 remaining uncertain. If this would becore a custom, that would
 be is an uncessary delay, an extra element thant would make sure thi=
ngs will not be done on time. But in a GOM, resolutions were always a=
dopted by HoDs of represented countries.
<u>There is no reason to fix what is not broken</u>, and thisGOM&nbsp=
; process has always been working very well so far, it is very far to=
 be broken. On the contrary, if we modify this process, other things =
will be more broken than ever, imho.<br>
<br>
&nbsp;&nbsp; What is broken is that many times resolutions are not ex=
ecuted promptly, without me wanting here to discuss about responsibil=
ities (which are not always the fact of one person). Our goal should =
be that resolutions be executed so that the work be done and
 publications achieved. <u>This process is broken</u>, <u>still</u>, =
and should be fixed as smoothly as possible.
<br>
<br>
&nbsp;&nbsp; GOMS are a winning process and should continue for inter=
im meetings. This is what I had understood in Saskatoon, and it seems=
 it was understood by others too (so far unanimously), according to t=
he reactions seen of the WG1 forum.<br>
<br>
Alain<br>
______________________________________<br>
Le 2014-01-26 =E0 08:22, Khalid Choukri a =E9crit :<br>
</font>
<blockquote type=3D"cite" class=3D"cite"><font size=3D"3">Content-Tra=
nsfer-Encoding: base64Dear colleagues<br>
<br>
Let me first express some astonishment regarding the reactions I have=
 read since Alain's email about the plenary versus GOM&nbsp; meetings=
, and our SC35 plans.<br>
<br>
I think we devote time to discuss this issue in Saskatoon and reviewe=
d all arguments pros and cons and the main conclusion was that we hea=
d to an annual meeting with a plenary, a WG meetings, and a resolutio=
n session; all running over 4 to 5 days.<br>
<br>
The intermediate meeting (the one in February this year) would be tur=
ned into a meeting of experts as required by the corresponding WG age=
nda (which means some WGs would skip that meeting if no item requires=
 a face to face meeting).<br>
<br>
<br>
So again, the proposed modus operandi as We discussed it in Saskatoon=
 would be:<br>
<br>
1/ (As long as necessary) a winter/spring technical meeting to addres=
s and make progress on technical matters that may (or not) lead to re=
solutions. This could be an opportunity to finalize WG reports that r=
equire face to face meeting of all experts.<br>
<br>
2/ An annual meeting with a plenary session to review the work progre=
ss, including the secretariat work and WG resolutions
<br>
<br>
3/ if a decision/action is taken during the technical meeting, the se=
cretariat will turn this into a resolution and bring it to adoption (=
electronic vote) and ensure its execution,<br>
<br>
We also discussed the scheduling of our meetings and many requirement=
s and desiderata were expressed: I would like to ensure participation=
 of all delegates (which excludes the major holiday seasons e.g. Chri=
stmas, Chinese new year, etc.) and necessitates a
 consensus for two-three years in advance.<br>
<br>
I have asked Philippe to circulate the details of the Barcelona meeti=
ng, I hope we will get it tomorrow (Monday). I understand that most o=
f us are upset because of the missing agenda and plans 10 days before=
 the meeting. I hope that you made your arrangements
 for your flights and will share with you informations on accommodati=
ons this week.<br>
<br>
Best regards<br>
Khalid <br>
<br>
<br>
&gt; Le 26 janv. 2014 =E0 11:13, Yoshikazu SEKI &lt;yoshikazu-seki@ai=
st.go.jp&gt; a =E9crit :<br>
&gt; <br>
&gt; Dear All,<br>
B&#143;=88H[=DB=C8=DD\=DC=80t Alain's position.<br>
&gt; <br>
&gt; We need to gather conclusions of WGs' meetings somehow, and also=
 need to have opportunity to know WGs' activities. We also need to de=
cide consolidated next actions after the meeting.<br>
&gt; <br>
=98\=D9Y=DB=88=D3=C0M model, we can have Resolutions even in the meet=
ing where the secretary is absent.<br>
&gt; <br>
=99\=DD=99Y=D8\=99=CBB&#143;=88B=82=AD=F0shikazu Seki<br>
B&#143;=88B&#143;=88=8CM=CCK=CC&#141;=88M=CE&#141;Nx=E0 O[=DB=9A\]YK=
=9BXZP=C0range.com&gt; &lt;monique.mai@orange.com&gt; =E3&#129;=AE=
=E3=83=A1=E3=83=BC=E3=83=AB=EF=BC=9A<br>
B=80&gt;&gt; Dear all,<br>
=88B&#143;=82f=97'7B=F6b=C6=C2=C2=92v=F7V=C6B=C6=AD=B6RF=F2v=976=82yo=
u a happy new year 2014 (sorry for sending this message late (my dad =
pass away at the end of 2013 and I was pretty busy in the begin of th=
e new year.)<br>
&gt;B&#143;&#143;=88=D9[=D9Hneed a &quot;strong cooperation between W=
G's in SC35&quot; and I fully understand, support Allan's position.
<br>
=88B&#143;=82=F6b6=F0urse, the model adapted during the last session =
can save of course expenses. Nethertheless, it really seems to me tha=
t the needs of a global meeting for having an overview of the activit=
ies of the different subgroup and the opportunity to get an exchange
 in face to face could be e an opportunity to wrap up the seminar, st=
imulate by this method the cooperation and a team spirit within the S=
C35. The collective creativity can emerge and I am sure it could be f=
inally an opportunity to stimulate all the energies
 in favour our trementous goal &quot;the accessibility&quot;.<br>
&gt;B=80&gt;&gt; If it is necessary, I propose to help Allan or to ac=
t for writting the resolutions if Philippe is not here (of course wit=
h his support).
<br>
&gt;B&#143;&#143;=88]YH=DB=9B=DD=C8Y=88\=C8roposal can help ; my curr=
ent vision is that a tremendous job was done and the cohesion of the =
SC35 is essential.
<br>
=88B&#143;=82f=F7&quot;=AD=F7W&quot;=AD=E6f=F7&amp;=D6F=AD=F6=E2=C2FV=
=E6=9726=8C:=A6=E6R=E6B=D7=976V=C6bttend the Barcelone meeting. We re=
ally think that we have to take in account the Allan, Keld, Jim comme=
nts.
<br>
=88@<br>
&gt;=99\=DD=99Y=D8\=99=CBB&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E2=D6=F6=E6=97VP=D0=A3=
=E3=E2=D0 =F8=804(=F8 <br>
&gt;&gt; <br>
&gt; <br>
&gt;B&#143;&#143;=88B=83=E2=D0=A3Q=94=80=E8&#129;=BD=DD=B9=95=C8=B5=
=CD=8C=CC=D5=DD=9C=C5=BDU=B8=B5=CD=D1&#144;=B9=BD=C9=9C&#129;m=B5=
=84ilto:owner-sc35wg1@open-std.org] De la part de ALB<br>
&gt;[=80voy=E9 : samedi 25 janvier 2014 14:41<br>
=880=E0=88=D9[=D9[^.com; Jee-In Kim<br>
&gt;&gt; Cc : Carter, James; Khalid CHOUKRI; sc35wg1@open-std.org; ph=
ilippe.magnabosco@afnor.org; amelle.mouradi@afnor.org<br>
&gt;=D8=9A=99]=88<br>
=D0=CC=CDU=D1=CCK&#141;NJH=91N=88=98Y&#157;Agenda - JTC1/SC35/WG1 mee=
ting - Barcelona, week of 10 February 2014<br>
&gt;B&#143;&#143;=88H=8CMLKL&#141;H0=E8=8CM=CB=D9[=D9[^=98=C0om =E9cr=
it:<br>
&gt;&gt;X\=88[B=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&#129;$&#129;=85=B1=CD=BC&#129;=
=CD=D5A=BD=C9=D0&#129;=B1=85=A5=B8=9Cs propositions.<br>
&#143;=88B=83=E3=E2=92=E6=F7FRF=86BF=86Rtw2v=AD=C6=C2=86fP resolution=
s, and that these resolutions should<br>
&gt;=88=99H=C0arried out bu the SC without unnessecary delay, eg. con=
firmed via a<br>
&gt;&gt;=D0=C8]\=88=98[=DD\=C8=D9H\=D9H=C8=C8=DA[=88=D9@ run GOMs.<br=
>
&gt;&gt; <br>
=88=D0[Z[=97H[=88=98X=DDY&#157;\=88[=D3=D3\=CB=99\=C0olutions were ex=
ecuted, we have not done letter ballots to vote on these resolutions =
later on.
<br>
&gt;B&#143;&#143;=88&#157;]=DA[=88a ballot was called by a resolution=
 for a NP, CD, DIS, PDTR, etc,, this ballot was done without extra fo=
rmality . This is the typical situation for most resolutions.<br>
=88@<br>
&gt;\=C8\=C8H[=DC=DDY=99=9AX=DAY[&#157;=D8^H=C8=9B=D8=D9YY[Z=9BB&#143=
;&#143;=88<br>
=88[Z[=83B&#143;&#143;=88B=83=E3=E2&amp;W2&amp;Vv&amp;G0=D0=A3=E0=
=F8&#129;-=95=B1&#144;4(&gt;&gt; <br>
&#143;=82=F6=E0 Fri, Jan 24, 2014 at 07:25:28PM &#43;0900, Jee-In Kim=
 wrote:<br>
&#143;=82FV&quot;=C6=C2=A3=E3=E0=F8=804(=F8&gt;&gt; I also support Al=
ain's position and interpretation.<br>
&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8&#129;]=94&#129;=C9=95=85=B1=B1=E4&#129;=B9=
=95=95&#144;&#129;=84&#129;=CD=D0rong cooperation between WG's in SC3=
5.<br>
&gt;&#143;=88=9B=DC=88^[\K we received a lot of valuable comments fro=
m experts in all WG's in SC35 to the 30113 series of gesture interfac=
es. That seems to me one of the great advantages of the GOM model. I =
expect that we need more cooperation in the future.<br>
&gt;&gt;=88B&#143;=83=E3=E2=C76=F2=C2vR6=E2&amp;RfW'=92&amp;=F6GV7F=
=97fRv=97F=82F=80e GOM model while relieving burdens and expenses of =
the secretariat. This seems a very practical solution to me.<br>
&gt;&gt;=88B&#143;=83=E3=E2&amp;W7B=A3=E0=F8=F8&#129;)=95=94=B5%=B8&#=
129;-=A5=B4=80=A1=A5A=85&#144;=A44(=F8&gt;&gt; <br>
&#143;=82#14. 1. 24. =CF=F3=F2s=A3b$6'FW&quot;=C2=A6=D6W2&quot;=C66'F=
W$72=E7W66=B2=E60a&gt; ??=CF=E0=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=804(=F8&gt;&gt;H=99[Y]=
=99H]\=99H\=99H=98\=9A[=DD\=C0 interpretations of what we discussed. =
Alain definitely discussed the GOM model as a means of meeting withou=
t plenary in the Saskatoon discussions. Given the context of history
 within SC35, many participants have a valid expectation that that wa=
s what was agreed to.<br>
&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8&#129;I=95=9Cards, Jim<br>
&#143;=83=E2g&amp;=F6=D3=A2=B6=86=C6=ADB4=84=F5T=B5$=92=B66=86=F7V=
=B7&amp;=94V=C6F=E6=F7&amp;u=D0=D0<br>
&gt;&#143;=826V=E7C=A2#B=A6=E7V'=92#B3=A33P=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8&#129;Q=
=BC=E8&#129;<br>
=85=C9=D1=95=C8=B0&#129;)=85=B4es; ALB; sc35wg1@open-std.org<br>
&gt;&#143;=8263=A2=86=AD=C6=97R=E6=D6v=E6&amp;=F0sco@afnor.org; amell=
e.mouradi@afnor.org<br>
&#143;=83=E27V&amp;=A6V7C=A2e: (SC35WG1.492) Draft Agenda - JTC1/SC35=
/WG1 meeting - Barcelona, week of 10 February 2014<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=88B=83=E3=E0=F8&#129;!=A4&#129;)=A5=B44<br>
&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8&#129;Q=A1=A5=CC&#129;=A5=CC&#129;=
=DD=A1=85=D0&#129;=DD=94&#129;=91=A5=CD&#141;=D5=CD=CD=95&#144;&#129;=
=85=B1=B0&#129;=D1=BD&#157;=95=D1=A1=95=C8&#129;=89=BD=D0h in Busan a=
nd Saskatoon and, after the discussions, I announced that we are head=
ing towards an annual plenary meeting with, as many as required, tech=
nical meetings.<br>
&#143;=80&gt; The agreement was that we have our plenaries in the sum=
mer (end of June, early July) and a technical one in February this ti=
me.<br>
&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8 Philippe:&nbsp; Could you please circulat=
e the info on the February meeting <br>
&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0&gt;&gt;B&#143;&#143;=83=E3=E2&amp;W7B&amp;Vv&am=
p;G2F=F2=C6=C2=A3=E0=F8=F8 Khalid<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=88B=80&gt;&gt;=88=D8\&#157;\=8B=98[Y\=C8=DC=9B=DDK=
=DB=88&#141;=CCK=CC=8CM&#141;=CE=83B&#143;&#143;=83=E3d=80strongly ag=
ree with Alain that the GOM model that we have historically used work=
s well to promote the well being and success of SC35 and that to do l=
ess would be to invite major problems in the working and success of
 SC35.<br>
&#143;=80&gt;&gt; <br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2&amp;Vv&amp;G2=C2=A6=AD=D0=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; _________=
_______________________<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2g&amp;=F6=D3=A2=C4&quot;=B6=C6&amp;=F6=E4v=D6=AD=A66=
=F6=D5=D0=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; Sent: 23 January 2014 08:25<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2F=F3=A2=B6=86=C6=ADB4=84=F5T=B5$=93=B2633Pwg1@open-std=
.org<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=8263=A2=86=AD=C6=97R=E6=D6v=E6&amp;=F766=F4f=E6=F7&quo=
t;=E6=F7 g; amelle.mouradi@afnor.org; Carter, James<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E27V&amp;=A6V0t: Re: (SC35WG1.492) Draft Agenda - JTC1/S=
C35/WG1 meeting - Barcelona, week of 10 February 2014<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8&gt; Khalid,<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; OK, I updated the timeframe of the =
agenda (see attached file, 2nd draft agenda).<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=86=F7vWfW&quot;=92F=86=AD=E6=B2F=86BF=86W&amp;R6=
=86=F7V=C6B&amp;R=D2=D22vR=86`e always done -- a P plenary session at=
 the end to have consolidated resolutions, not dispersed resolutions =
in each WG (AFNOR used to call such a meeting a GOM [General Orientat=
ion Meeting, a term invented by them for
 meetings where the secretariat was absent, a situation with which we=
 got used to and to which we adapted as it seemed the best solution i=
n this case] when it was not a formal Plenary). Otherwise I strongly =
fear that SC35 will be weakened, disorganized, and
 incoherent between formal plenaries (we need to be sure that decisio=
ns will be cared about and focused in a central point). The sentiment=
 of &quot;belonging&quot; will also vanish, and groups will feel auto=
nomous (let's then form a different SC !) or not cared about
 (one situation or the other, not much in between). The net result, i=
mho, will be that interest in attendance could go down. That is my ex=
perience of JTC1&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; meetings since more th=
an a quarter century.<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 We have always have consolidated =
resolutions since the creation of SC35 in 1999 (SC35 was created by J=
TC1 at its Rio de Janeiro Plenary in January 1999, I was there -- out=
 of JTC1/WG5, itself out of JTC1/SC18/WG9). This strenghtened SC35 al=
l the
 time, making it a coherent body. When the secretary was not there, I=
 was acting as resolution secretary (no problem in my doing so again,=
 and many other people could also do so -- in any way I can still vol=
unteer if this is a problem).<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8&gt; About future meetings, I think th=
at we must have strong hints (at least a firm date and a firm contine=
nt, ideally a firm country) for 18 months in advance (funds planning =
is typically done -- depending on countries -- on a civil year, from =
January
 to December or from another month up to the next eleven months over =
spanning civil years [in Canada as a case in point from April to Marc=
h of the next civil year). In absence of those strong hints, funds ha=
ve more chances not to be sufficiently available,
 which is also very much detrimental to sustainable attendance.<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 I'm pretty sure that other conven=
ors will agree with me. If not, I'm ready to modestly say I have a di=
ssident view and would then accept the views of the majority.<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8&gt; Alain<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=
=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=
=F0=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 Le 2014-01-23 =E0 06:13, Khalid CHOUKRI a =E9cr=
it :<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=86=92=C6=AD=E0=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 <br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=822w&amp;VVBB=F7W&quot;66=B6@oon meeting there will be=
 no &quot;Plenary&quot; sessions per see in Barcelona,<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; I hope to join the group and introd=
uce the activities of the week but this could be an informal introduc=
tion on Monday morning , Philippe is looking at that and this should =
not last more than 30mn;<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8&gt; The same decision impacts the clo=
sing session (there will be no closing meeting and hence no resolutio=
n session), I hope to be able to attend a general gathering (may be o=
n Thursday) to wrap up and see how we move forward with respect to th=
e July
 meeting.<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0&gt;&gt;=88=99Y=D8\=99[=99=C8[=DD\=88][H=
=DB=88&#157;]\=99HYY][=99=DC=C8H=DDY=D9=D9\=DD=C8leave this out unles=
s you would like to get the participants desiderata (and hopefully Ph=
ilippe will circulate the invitation from our Chinese partners before=
 Barcelona)<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 thanks again and best wishes to a=
ll for a successful meeting in Barcelona<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8&gt; Khalid<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8&gt; P.S. Philippe: could you please u=
pdate the SC35 action list, in particular with the information you go=
t from Spain, thanks<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 <br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=C6=AD=E0 LaBont=EF=B0=AFH=DC=9B=DDK=DB=88=8C=8B=
=CCK=CC=8CMN=8C=8EN=83B&#143;=83=E3=E0=F8&#129;M=95=94&#129;=85=D1=
=D0ached file. Please indicate omissions, errors, if any, and suggest=
 other areas of concerns.<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 Any other remark also welcome.<br=
>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8 Alain LaBont=E9, Convenor, JTC1/S=
C35/WQG1<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2\:=AD&amp;V0=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; <br>
&#143;=80&gt;&gt; ---<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E26R6=F7W'&amp;=ADW&quot;:=AD=C6V7G&amp;=F6=E6=97VR=E6R6=
=F6=E7F=ADV=E7BV7Pn virus ou logiciel malveillant parce que la protec=
tion avast! Antivirus est active.<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=87GG=A2=F2=F7wwr=E6f7B=E66=F6=D2<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; --<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=D0=A3=E0=F8=F8&gt; Khalid Choukri<br>
&gt;&gt;&gt;&gt;S&#144;H=D9[=99\=98[=D9X=DC=99]\=9EH&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp=
; =88SH=D1S=C2&#143;&#143;=83=E3U=B5=85=A5=B0=E8&#129;&#141;=A1=BD=
=D4kri@elda.org&lt; <a href=3D"mailto:choukri@elda.org" target=3D"_bl=
ank">
mailto:choukri@elda.org</a>&gt;;<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2vV#=A2wwr=E0elra.info &lt; <a href=3D"UrlBlockedError.=
aspx" target=3D"_blank">http://www.elra.info=DD=DD=CB=99[K=9B=DC=99=
=C8=8B=CB=DD=C0ww.elda.org/</a>&gt;<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=82FV=A2=B332C223232=D2f=82=E2=B33243 13 33 30<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; ***********************************=
****************<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=A2=A2=AD=E6f=F2=F6=E2=C5$T3=A2wwr=E6=C7&amp;Pc-conf.o=
rg &lt; <a href=3D"http://www.lrec-conf.org/" target=3D"_blank">
http://www.lrec-conf.org</a>&gt;<br>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2=A2 *************************=
*****************<br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; <br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; <br>
&#143;=83=E3=E2=D0 =F8=F8&gt;&gt; ________________________________<br=
>
&gt;&#143;=83=E2=B2=87GG=A2=F2=F77FF=AD2=E6f7B=E66=F6=D2=F6V=D6=AD=
=C72=F6vast-mail-stamp.png] &lt; <a href=3D"http://www.avast.com/B=
=83%E3%E0%F8%F8=804(%3E%3E%8F=88%D9H%DB%DD/=9C=9AY/=880%EA%5BX%DD=
=9B%DB=9A/%5DYH=99H%DB%DB%9DY%5B%9D%5DX%DD%5B=88=9A/%9D/%C8%C0u" targ=
et=3D"_blank">
http://www.avast.com/B=83=E3=E0=F8=F8=804(&gt;&gt;&#143;=88=D9H=DB=
=DD\=9C=9AY\=880=EA[X=DD=9B=DB=9A\]YH=99H=DB=DB&#157;Y[&#157;]X=DD[=
=88=9A\&#157;\=C8=C0u</a> logiciel malveillant parce que la protectio=
n Antivirus avast!&lt;
<a href=3D"http://www.avast.com//%DDX%DD%5D=99K=83B=83%E3%E0%F8=804(%=
F8" target=3D"_blank">http://www.avast.com/\=DDX=DD]=99K=83B=83=E3=
=E0=F8=804(=F8</a>&gt;&gt; --
<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=88B=83=E3=E0=F8&#129;-=A1=85=B1=A5&#144;&#129;<br>
=A1=BD=D5=AD=C9=A4=804(=F8&gt;&gt;S&#144;H=D9[=99\=98[=C0ecretary &am=
p; ELDA CEO <br>
&gt;&#143;=82V=D6=AD=E26=86=F7V=B7&amp;=94V=C6F=E6=F7&amp;s=B2=D0=
=A3=E0&gt;&gt;=D9X=8E=88=DD=DD=CB=99[=98K=9A[=99=9B=C8=DD=DD=CB=99[K=
=9B=DC=99=C8B=83=E3=E0=F8&#129;Q=95=B0=B8=80=AC=CC=CC=80=C4=80=D0=
=CC 13 33 33 - Fax. &#43;33 1 43 13 33 30
<br>
&gt;&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E0=F8=F8=80=A8=A8=A8=A8=A8=A8*****************=
****************************<br>
&#143;=83=E2=A2=A2&#144;nfo on LREC: <a href=3D"http://www.lrec-conf.=
org/" target=3D"_blank">www.lrec-conf.org</a>
<br>
&gt;&gt;&#143;=88<br>
=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=8A=80***************=
*******************<br>
&gt;&gt; <br>
=88B&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E2Ce courrier =E9lectronique ne contient aucun=
 virus ou logiciel malveillant parce que la protection Antivirus avas=
t! est active.<br>
=88B&#143;=82=D0=A3=E3=E2=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=
=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F5=F0_____________________=
_____________________________________________________________________=
_<br>
&gt;&gt; <br>
=88=D9HY\=DC=D8Y=D9H] ses pieces jointes peuvent contenir des informa=
tions confidentielles ou privilegiees et ne doivent donc<br>
&gt;\=C8@tre diffuses, exploites ou copies sans autorisation. Si vous=
 avez recu ce message par erreur, veuillez le signaler<br>
=88H&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp;&nbsp; =D9^Y]]\=88]H]&#157;Z\=99HZ[=
=9C=DAH]YH\=C8YX=D9\=C8=80ointes. Les messages electroniques etant su=
sceptibles d'alteration,<br>
&gt;&gt; Orange decline toute responsabilite si ce message a ete alte=
re, deforme ou falsifie. Merci.<br>
&gt;&gt; <br>
&gt; This message and its attachments may contain confidential or pri=
vileged information that may be protected by law;<br>
&gt;&gt; they should not be distributed, used or copied without autho=
risation.<br>
=88Y=88[=DDH]=99H=99X=D9Z]=99Y\=C8[XZ[[=80 error, please notify the s=
ender and delete this message and its attachments.<br>
&gt;\=C8[XZ[=C8X^H=99H[\=99Y=DC=98[=99=D9@ is not liable for messages=
 that have been modified, changed or falsified.<br>
&gt;[=9A=C8[=DDK=83B&#143;=88B=82=D0=A3=E2=D0=A3=E2=D2=D2=D0 =804(&gt=
; Yoshikazu SEKI, Ph.D.<br>
&gt; Senior Research Scientist<br>
&gt; Physical Fitness Technology Group*,<br>
&gt; Human Technology Research Institute,<br>
&gt; National Institute of Advanced Industrial Science and Technology=
 (AIST).<br>
<br>
=88=DC=9B=DD\=DA[=99=D9Y=80une 1, 2013.<br>
B&#143;=88KLKLHY=D8\=DAK=DDZ=DDX=98KX=98\=98Z=DAH=CC<br>
KN566 JAPAN.<br>
&gt; Phone: &#43;81-29-861-6716,<br>
&gt; Fax: &#43;81-29-861-6774&nbsp; *Fax number also changed.<br>
&gt; E-mail: yoshikazu-seki@aist.go.jp<br>
&gt; Web : <a href=3D"http://staff.aist.go.jp/yoshikazu-seki/" target=
=3D"_blank">http://staff.aist.go.jp/yoshikazu-seki/</a><br>
B=80</font></blockquote>
<br>
<br>
<hr style=3D"border:none; color:#909090; background-color:#B0B0B0; he=
ight:1px; width:99%">
<table style=3D"border-collapse:collapse; border:none">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td style=3D"border:none; padding:0px 15px 0px 8px"><a href=3D"http:/=
/www.avast.com/" target=3D"_blank"><img src=3D"http://static.avast.co=
m/emails/avast-mail-stamp.png" border=3D"0">
</a></td>
<td>
<p style=3D"color:#3d4d5a; font-family:&quot;Calibri&quot;,&quot;Verd=
ana&quot;,&quot;Arial&quot;,&quot;Helvetica&quot;; font-size:12pt">
Ce courrier =E9lectronique ne contient aucun virus ou logiciel malvei=
llant parce que la protection
<a href=3D"http://www.avast.com/" target=3D"_blank">Antivirus avast!<=
/a> est active. </p>
</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<br>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</body>
</html>

--Boundary_(ID_NPWKgRaARwrsQpvMGIKavA)--
